|
UDDER FACTS
Paul Brown MANAGING DIRECTOR
The situation is simple. There is little to no spare
money in dairy farming cash flows because :
- Payout advances are slow to increase to final payout levels
- Banks have choker holds on purse strings
- Production for this season has been poor to average in many areas (some areas have had very good seasons)
The payouts are slowly improving but in areas of poor / average MS production, the cash flows have been
further tightened causing real problems. This will come right of course around October but there are a lot of costs between now and then.
While the 'banks' are being blamed for most of the liquidity problems (which is slightly unfair)
they have two choices of pathway. It is clear they want to decrease their exposure in New Zealand dairying. They could ease cash flows by calculating final seasonal production etc
and letting limits stretch accordingly. By doing this they would ease the pain levels without lifting farm costs. Option 2, is they can keep the choker hold on and possibly stall dairying
completely. By this I mean unless, for example, cash flows ease up with guarantees of $$ being available to pay for winter grazing and stock purchases, then terms of trade will alter to
adapt – cash up front! (This may happen anyway as a result of last winter.) The issue is
that the seasonal activities must carry on, they just cannot be put onto a shelf and forgotten about for several months. Also support industries need to pay their bills and dairy farmers
must pay their way, under the terms of the agreement.
The problem is, with little spare cash, cows could be underfed again this winter, dry cow
therapy be skimped on, cows dried off in light condition etc. Obviously each farmer must adapt but in my observations up to 50% of the dairy industry is still under severe financial
pressure. Fonterra wants more milk, the banks want more milk, farmers want more milk – hence more money, so let the cows do their job!
Last season most dairy farms decreased cow numbers by 5 – 10% to adapt to the $4
payout. Now, at $6 most farms need to increase by 5 – 10%. However, the cash flow problems are preventing many farmers from buying stock as overdraft limits will not allow this
. Budget cows etc can be a good, cheap, short term solution, but unless they are purchased April / May they go to the works, leaving only more expensive options available.
Winter grazing must be paid for May to August so there is no point coming up with the $$ in October!
Another result of poor liquidity is the “in milk” market. August / October could be strong as
payout advances hence cash flows, should be slightly better as cows are in milk and wintered but could be overvalued. So surely one should consider buying cheaper budget
cows. One point most farmers do concede is that because of the banks' hold, farm costs
have held, not risen. If this can be maintained within reason it will allow profitability to return
to farms without causing competition based inflation, ie winter grazing. This way, over time, farming profitability will return and banks can extract their dollars. The question is, do we
need to go through this stress or could it be eased by less of a choker hold?
WINTER GRAZING Winter is looming and farmers are wondering about winter grazing prices. The parameters effecting prices this season are :
- Low cropping prices
- Very poor cashflows
- Lamb/sheep margins are fair to low
- Beef margins also fair to low
Therefore, winter grazing costs should not rise on last year's prices and it will depend upon
how much is available. With Otago being very dry, those cows are heading into Canterbury and Southland which is putting pressure on feed supplies. However, a good growing climate
April / May will influence crop yields significantly. There are also good supplies of silage on
hand. Overall, I believe they should be similar to last year with possibly a slight lift due to demand from Otago area.
MARKET PRICES The livestock markets have fluctuated this season with payout perceptions etc but has
fluctuated less overall than the last two years. Lately, prices have softened but good high BW herds have held their values well. Bargain hunters are about, picking off weaker
negotiators and there are some good cows left but not heaps. There are plenty of in calf
heifers especially half / unrecorded and fully recorded, good BW heifers are selling well.
Budget cows are starting to appear but most will end in the works as there are few buyers yet.
R1 year heifer calves are very strong in price – for some reason. However, lately this has eased but are still overvalued on today's market.
Culls are coming out fast now and as usual, prices will fall as the works need to make a profit from these, and there is no point hanging onto them while they become weightier. The
US market is high, building NZ prices.
|